Skip to content

Head to head

Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara vs Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect MascaraessenceLash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara8.0Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye LinerStilaStay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner8.1vs

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner edges out essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, 8.1 to 8.0. It wins on performance, wear time and shade range, while the Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara is stronger on value and community love.

Benefit fingerprints

What each one does.

essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara

HydrateClarifyRenewGlowCalm & ProtectHair & ScalpFinish & WearScentMoistureBarrierBreakoutsOil & PoresCleanseLines & FirmnessTextureEye AreaEven ToneRadianceSensitiveProtectRepairShape & ShineScalpFinishWearCoverageLashes & BrowsFloralGourmandFreshWoody & AmberHydratingPlumpingLong-lasting moistureBarrier repairDryness reliefFlaking reliefAcneBlackheadsClogged poresOil controlPore refiningShine controlMakeup removalDouble cleansingFine linesFirmingCrepinessSmoothingResurfacingBumps & KPDark circlesPuffinessDark spotsHyperpigmentationAcne marksBrighteningDullnessGlass skinSoothingRednessIrritation-freeUV protectionNo white castAntioxidantOdor controlDamage repairSplit endsHeat protectionCurl definitionFrizz controlVolumeShineScalp careHair growth supportDandruffColor protectionMatteDewySatinNaturalLong-wearTransfer-proofWaterproofBuildableSheer coverageMedium coverageFull coverageBlurringLash lengthLash volumeCurl holdBrow definitionFloralWhite floralRoseVanillaGourmandCaramelCitrusFresh & cleanAquaticGreenWoodyAmberMuskySpicyHydrateClarifyRenewGlowHair & ScalpFinish & WearScent

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

HydrateClarifyRenewGlowCalm & ProtectHair & ScalpFinish & WearScentMoistureBarrierBreakoutsOil & PoresCleanseLines & FirmnessTextureEye AreaEven ToneRadianceSensitiveProtectRepairShape & ShineScalpFinishWearCoverageLashes & BrowsFloralGourmandFreshWoody & AmberHydratingPlumpingLong-lasting moistureBarrier repairDryness reliefFlaking reliefAcneBlackheadsClogged poresOil controlPore refiningShine controlMakeup removalDouble cleansingFine linesFirmingCrepinessSmoothingResurfacingBumps & KPDark circlesPuffinessDark spotsHyperpigmentationAcne marksBrighteningDullnessGlass skinSoothingRednessIrritation-freeUV protectionNo white castAntioxidantOdor controlDamage repairSplit endsHeat protectionCurl definitionFrizz controlVolumeShineScalp careHair growth supportDandruffColor protectionMatteDewySatinNaturalLong-wearTransfer-proofWaterproofBuildableSheer coverageMedium coverageFull coverageBlurringLash lengthLash volumeCurl holdBrow definitionFloralWhite floralRoseVanillaGourmandCaramelCitrusFresh & cleanAquaticGreenWoodyAmberMuskySpicyHydrateClarifyRenewGlowHair & ScalpFinish & WearScent

Side by side

Every detail, compared.

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or what we recommend. How we make money

essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara

essence

Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Stila

Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

Highest score
Beauty score
8.0Great
8.1Great
Payoff & performance30% of score
8.2
8.5
Wear time15% of score
7.0
8.4
Shade range & inclusivity15% of score
6.0
8.2
Value20% of score
9.6
7.0
Community love20% of score
8.4
8.1
Community
No ratings yet
No ratings yet
PriceTypical, checked by our editors
$4.99/ 0.4 ozDrugstore
$25.00/ 0.016 oz / 0.5 mlMid-range
Price per ounceLowest wins
—
$1,478.68 / oz
What it does
  • Lash volume
  • Lash length
  • Buildable
  • Long-wear
  • Waterproof
  • Long-wear
  • Transfer-proof
Made for
All skin types
All skin types
Format
Mascara
Eyeliner
Texture
Black volumizing formula applied with a conical fiber brush
Quick-drying liquid liner dispensed through an ultra-precise, marker-like tip
Finish
—
Satin
ShadesMore wins
—
12
Fragrance-free
—
—
Claims
Cruelty-free (brand-stated), Paraben-free
Leaping Bunny certified, Cruelty-free (brand-stated)
Brand origin
🇩🇪 German skincare
🇺🇸 American beauty
Video reviews
5
5
Best for
  • • Budget shoppers who want dramatic volume
  • • Straight or sparse lashes that need a lot of grab
  • • Trying a viral mascara with little financial risk
  • • Winged and cat-eye liner looks
  • • Oily lids or humid weather that break down washable liners
  • • Anyone wanting a liquid liner in brown or color
Strengths
  • Very low $4.99 price
  • Conical fiber brush grabs small lashes for a false-lash look
  • Cruelty-free and paraben-free per the brand
  • Precise marker-like tip for wings and thin lines
  • Waterproof, smudge-proof and transfer-proof claims
  • Twelve shades including browns and bright colors
Watch-outs
  • Several users report smudging, transfer or mid-day flaking
  • Limited shade choice compared with other mascaras
  • Small 0.016 oz fill for the $25 price
  • Contains parabens, which some shoppers avoid
Where to buy
Check price on AmazonBuy from the brand$25.00

Affiliate links — we may earn a commission. How we make money

FAQ

Quick answers.

Which is better, Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara or Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner?

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner edges out essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara, 8.1 to 8.0. It wins on performance, wear time and shade range, while the Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara is stronger on value and community love.

Which costs less?

essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara typically sells for about $4.99 and Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner for about $25.00, based on retail prices when we last checked.

How do you score them?

Both are scored on the same five-factor rubric (payoff & performance, wear time, shade range & inclusivity, value, community love), using the formula or specs, verified creator reviews, community consensus and value. Brands can’t pay for placement.