Head to head
Vanilla | 28 Eau de Parfum vs Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette
KAYALI Vanilla | 28 Eau de Parfum edges out Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette, 7.4 to 7.3. It wins on longevity, versatility and value, while the Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette is stronger on the scent itself and community love.
Benefit fingerprints
What each one does.
KAYALI Vanilla | 28 Eau de Parfum
Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette
Side by side
Every detail, compared.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or what we recommend. How we make money
KAYALI
Vanilla | 28 Eau de Parfum
Highest score- Vanilla
- Gourmand
- Amber
- Spicy
- Woody
- Spicy
- Vanilla
- Amber
- top
- Vanilla Orchid, Creamy Jasmine
- heart
- Vanilla Infusion, Vanilla Surabsolute, Tonka
- base
- Brown Sugar, Musk, Patchouli, Amber
- top
- Pink Pepper, Orange Flower Absolute, Clove Oil
- heart
- Chestnut Accord, Gaiac Wood Oil, Cade Oil
- base
- Vanilla Accord, Peru Balsam Resinoid, Cashmeran
- • Vanilla and gourmand lovers
- • Cold-weather signature scents
- • Layering under fruitier or floral perfumes
- • Cold-weather and holiday wear
- • Fans of smoky gourmands and woods
- • Anyone wanting a unisex cozy signature scent
- Rich, warm vanilla with tonka, brown sugar and amber
- Designed for layering with other KAYALI scents
- Good longevity for a gourmand according to many wearers
- Distinctive smoky chestnut, clove and vanilla accord that matches its theme
- Unisex and cozy for fall and winter
- Layers well with other gourmand and woody scents
- Divisive: some find it too sweet, musky or synthetic
- Expensive, with many cheaper dupes in circulation
- $170 for 100 ml of eau de toilette is steep
- Smoky campfire note is polarizing; some liken it to a barbecue
Affiliate links — we may earn a commission. How we make money
Affiliate links — we may earn a commission. How we make money
FAQ
Quick answers.
Which is better, Vanilla | 28 Eau de Parfum or Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette?
KAYALI Vanilla | 28 Eau de Parfum edges out Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette, 7.4 to 7.3. It wins on longevity, versatility and value, while the Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette is stronger on the scent itself and community love.
Which is better value?
KAYALI Vanilla | 28 Eau de Parfum works out to about $44.36 / oz and Maison Margiela Replica By the Fireplace Eau de Toilette to about $50.27 / oz, based on typical non-Amazon retail prices when we last checked.
How do you score them?
Both are scored on the same five-factor rubric (scent quality, longevity & projection, versatility, value, community love), using the formula or specs, verified creator reviews, community consensus and value. Brands can’t pay for placement.