Head to head
Shape Tape Concealer vs All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer edges out Urban Decay All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray, 8.2 to 7.5. It wins on performance, shade range and value, while the All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray is stronger on wear time.
Benefit fingerprints
What each one does.
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
Urban Decay All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray
Side by side
Every detail, compared.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or what we recommend. How we make money
- Full coverage
- Matte
- Long-wear
- Waterproof
- Long-wear
- Waterproof
- Transfer-proof
- Natural
- • Covering dark circles and blemishes with full coverage
- • Oily and combination skin that wants a matte, long-wear concealer
- • Deeper skin tones looking for a close concealer match
- • Oily and combination skin that needs makeup to survive heat and humidity
- • Long days and events where transfer resistance matters
- • Shoppers who never used the original formula
- Full, brightening coverage for dark circles, redness and blemishes
- 48 shades, including a wide run of deep and rich options
- 0.33 fl oz tube holds more than most prestige concealers
- Claims up to 24-hour wear that is waterproof, sweat- and transfer-resistant
- Ultra-fine mist that the brand says sprays evenly without disturbing makeup
- Natural, soft-blur finish suited to oily and combination skin
- Some Reddit users report heavy creasing or a look that sits on top of the skin
- Matte formula targets oily and combination skin; Tarte steers dry skin to Shape Tape Creamy
- Many longtime fans on Reddit call the reformulation inferior to the Skindinavia-made original
- Denatured alcohol is the second ingredient, which can bother very dry or reactive skin
Affiliate links — we may earn a commission. How we make money
Affiliate links — we may earn a commission. How we make money
FAQ
Quick answers.
Which is better, Shape Tape Concealer or All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray?
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer edges out Urban Decay All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray, 8.2 to 7.5. It wins on performance, shade range and value, while the All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray is stronger on wear time.
Which costs less?
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer typically sells for about $32.00 and Urban Decay All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray for about $34.00, based on retail prices when we last checked.
How do you score them?
Both are scored on the same five-factor rubric (payoff & performance, wear time, shade range & inclusivity, value, community love), using the formula or specs, verified creator reviews, community consensus and value. Brands can’t pay for placement.